When cost savings is the main driver of a sourcing initiative, many consider looking at what is available abroad, in countries where both labor rates and material costs are known to be more competitive than in the US.

Nearshoring and offshoring are two popular strategies that can help companies achieve these goals. However, deciding which strategy is right for your business can be complex. According to the Asian Development Bank, outsourcing procurement functions has become a strategic move for both public and private sectors, allowing organizations to focus on core competencies while leveraging specialized procurement agents

This blog post will provide you with the information you need to make an informed decision about nearshoring vs offshoring in procurement.

What is Nearshoring?

Nearshoring refers to the practice of outsourcing goods or services to a country that is geographically close to your own. This can offer several advantages, such as:

• Shorter lead times: Because nearshore suppliers are located closer, there is less time required for transportation.
• Reduced transportation costs: Transportation costs can be a significant factor in the total cost of goods or services. Nearshoring can help to reduce these costs.
• Easier communication and collaboration: When working with nearshore suppliers, there is less of a time difference and cultural barrier, which can make communication and collaboration easier.

Latin America: Mexico has emerged as a significant player, especially for U.S. companies looking to minimize transportation costs and leverage proximity. The country benefits from favorable trade agreements and a skilled labor force, particularly in manufacturing and assembly operations.

What is Offshoring?

Offshoring refers to the practice of outsourcing goods or services to a country that is located far away from your own. This can offer several advantages, such as:

• Lower labor costs: Offshoring is often associated with lower labor costs. However, it is important to factor in other costs, such as transportation costs and import duties.
• Access to a wider talent pool: Offshoring can give you access to a wider talent pool, which can be beneficial if you are looking for specialized skills or expertise.

Asia: Countries like China, India, Vietnam, and the Philippines are prominent outsourcing destinations due to their competitive labor costs and growing capabilities in various sectors. The Philippines, in particular, has been highlighted for its large, educated workforce and cultural alignment with Western businesses, making it a preferred choice for IT and customer service outsourcing.

Eastern Europe: Countries like Poland and Ukraine are increasingly being recognized for their technical skills and cost-effective services, particularly in IT and software development. This region is attractive for companies seeking to outsource tech-related functions while maintaining quality. (Source: Offshore Outsourcing: Industry Trends in 2023)

Nearshoring vs Offshoring: Which is Right for You?

The decision of whether to nearshore or offshore depends on a number of factors, including:

• Cost: Cost is a major consideration for any procurement decision. You will need to weigh the potential cost savings of offshoring against the additional costs of transportation, communication, and collaboration.
• Lead time: If lead time is a critical factor for your business, then nearshoring may be the better option.
• Quality: The quality of goods or services can vary depending on the supplier’s location. It is important to carefully evaluate the quality of potential suppliers before making a decision.
• Risk: Both nearshoring and offshoring involve risks. For example, there is a greater risk of political instability in some offshore locations.
• Compliance: You must ensure that your nearshore or offshore supplier complies with all applicable laws and regulations.
• Culture: Cultural differences can significantly impact a project or business if not handled properly. Flexibility and the ability to adapt to a different culture on some levels may be necessary to minimize risks and maximize benefits.

Conclusion

There is no easy answer to the question of whether to nearshore or offshore. The best strategy for your business will depend on a number of factors. By carefully considering the factors discussed in this blog post, you can make an informed decision that will help you to achieve your procurement goals.

Additional Tips

• When considering nearshoring or offshoring, it is important to develop a strong relationship with your supplier. This will help to ensure that you are getting the quality and service that you need.
• It is also important to visit your supplier’s facilities in person before making a decision. This will give you a chance to assess their capabilities and ensure that they are a good fit for your business.

How has COVID-19 impacted Nearshoring and Offshoring?

The COVID-19 pandemic has disrupted global supply chains and caused many companies to rethink their sourcing strategies. As a result, there has been a trend towards nearshoring. This is because nearshoring can help to reduce the risks associated with long supply chains.

The Future of Nearshoring and Offshoring

The future of nearshoring and offshoring is uncertain. However, both strategies are likely to continue to play a role in global procurement. The best strategy for your business will depend on the specific circumstances of your industry and your company’s needs.

Visit NLPA Learning, the new home to all of our certifications and online courses. The Learning site also includes learning resources, including live and on-demand webinars, publications and reports, articles, templates, white papers, and much more!

Recommended Reading

• Outsourcing Procurement: Pros & Cons
• The First Steps of International Sourcing
• What is Global Sourcing?
• Expert Procurement Operations Management
• Organizing Procurement Department Operations
• Are Your Procurement Operations Dashboarded?